Investigation 10

Energy Dynamics

What factors govern energy capture, allocation, storage, and transfer between producers and consumers in a terrestrial ecosystem?

Unit 8: EcologyENE-1.MENE-1.NENE-1.OSYI-3.AScience Practices 6.C, 6.D≈ 2–3 weeks of short sessionsAbout 130 minutes in total
Overview

Running an energy budget for a tiny ecosystem

You will build a two-species model ecosystem: Wisconsin Fast Plants (Brassica rapa) as the producer and cabbage white butterfly larvae (Pieris rapae) as the consumer. By tracking biomass and converting it to kilocalories, you will account for energy the way an accountant tracks money: what comes in, what is stored, and what is spent.

In the real lab these steps take two to three weeks. Here the plants grow in a few clicks, but you still have to make the measurements, do the calculations, and decide what your numbers mean.

What you will do
  • Part 1: Harvest Fast Plants at two ages, dry them, and use dry mass (biomass) to estimate net primary productivity (NPP). Then measure plant respiration to estimate gross primary productivity (GPP).
  • Part 2: Feed 4th-instar larvae a Brussels sprout for 3 days. Measure what they eat, how much they grow, and how much frass (waste) they produce, then audit where the energy went.
  • Part 3: Design your own investigation of light, temperature, crowding, fertilizer, or food type.
Learning objectives
  • ENE-1.M Describe the strategies organisms use to acquire and use energy.
  • ENE-1.N Explain how changes in energy availability affect populations and ecosystems.
  • ENE-1.O Explain how the activities of autotrophs and heterotrophs enable the flow of energy within an ecosystem.
  • SYI-3.A Connect variation in the molecules within organisms to their ability to survive and reproduce in different environments.
  • Science practices 6.C, 6.D Justify claims with evidence and connect results to larger biological concepts.
Safety and care of organisms
  • The USDA lists cabbage white butterflies as a pest. Never release larvae or adults outdoors. When the work is done, larvae and butterflies are euthanized by freezing; plants and soil can be thrown away.
  • Never put research organisms under extreme stress, such as high temperatures. That is why the design options below limit larval temperatures to a humane range.
  • Keep growing chambers clean (wipe with dilute bleach, then dry) to avoid disease outbreaks, and keep water away from the light fixtures.
Background

Biomass is how we count energy

Key ideas
  • Producers capture energy as gross primary productivity (GPP); what is left after plant respiration is net primary productivity (NPP).
  • Dry mass is biomass: water holds no usable energy, so you dry organisms and convert grams to kcal.
  • A larva's intake splits three ways: C = P + R + F (growth, respiration, frass).
  • Respiration is found by difference, so it carries the error from every other measurement.
  • Each transfer loses energy as heat, so little reaches the next trophic level.

Almost every food web runs on sunlight. During photosynthesis, producers capture light energy and store it in the chemical bonds of sugars and other organic molecules. Those molecules become the plant's body: its biomass. The total rate at which producers capture energy is gross primary productivity (GPP). Plants spend part of that energy right away on their own cellular respiration (R). What is left over and stored as new tissue is net primary productivity (NPP).

NPP = GPP − Rplant
From mass to energy: why dry mass

We cannot count kilocalories directly, but organic molecules have mass, so we can measure biomass and convert. The catch is water. A living Fast Plant is mostly water, and water stores no usable chemical energy. That is why ecologists dry organisms in an oven (about 100 °C for 48 hours) and weigh the dry mass. The dry-to-wet ratio (the "percent biomass") lets you estimate the biomass of living things you do not want to kill, such as a Brussels sprout you are about to feed to larvae.

energy (kcal) = wet mass (g) × (dry ÷ wet) × energy per gram of dry mass

Different molecules hold different amounts of energy: about 4 kcal per gram for carbohydrates and proteins, about 9 kcal per gram for fats. In this lab you will use measured averages from bomb calorimetry: 4.35 kcal/g for dry plant biomass, 5.5 kcal/g for dry larval biomass (larvae store more fat), and 4.76 kcal/g for dry frass.

Where a larva's energy goes: C = P + R + F

When a larva eats, the energy it consumes (C) splits three ways. Some passes through the gut undigested and leaves as frass, which is egested energy (F). The rest is assimilated (A) into the body. Of the assimilated energy, some builds new tissue (production, P) and the rest is used in cellular respiration and lost as heat (R). Because energy is neither created nor destroyed, the budget must balance:

C = P + R + F   →   R = C − P − F

Respiration is hard to measure directly in a caterpillar, so you will estimate it as the energy left over after the other terms are measured. Every conversion loses energy as heat, which is the second law of thermodynamics at work. That is why only a small fraction of the energy at one trophic level shows up as biomass in the next.

Energy flow diagram
Energy flow: light to plant (GPP), plant respiration and NPP; NPP eaten by larva splits into frass, growth and respiration Lightsun / grow lights Fast PlantGPP capturedNPP stored as biomass Larvaeats (C), assimilates (A)grows (P) Frass (F)to decomposers heat (Rplant) heat (Rlarva) eaten Arrow widths in your own data diagrams (Parts 1 and 2) will be drawn to scale.
What this simulation models
  • Process: Energy flow in a food chain. Fast Plants store part of the captured energy as biomass (NPP); cabbage white larvae store some of what they eat, respire some and egest the rest.
  • Included: Plant dry mass growing with age, plant-to-plant vigor, dry fraction and dark respiration (measured as CO2); design factors of light, temperature, crowding and fertilizer; larval growth, food eaten, frass, sprout water loss (the control), food type and temperature.
  • Simplified or left out: Growth follows a curve fitted to the lab manual, not real photosynthesis, and energy uses fixed kcal-per-gram values. Pests, disease, water stress and larval deaths are not modeled, so real data vary more.
Pre-lab check

Getting started: the energy accountant's toolkit

These items review the setup tasks and the conversions you will use. Use a calculator.

Procedure 1 · Structured inquiry

Estimating net primary productivity of Fast Plants

Before you begin: Record wet mass and dry mass in separate fields, using grams. Then use the recorded values for the energy calculations.

Need a quick science reminder?

Dry mass excludes water; it is not interchangeable with wet mass. Keep grams, kilocalories and per-day rates distinct.

Biomass to energy

Energy stored (kcal) = dry mass (g) × energy density (kcal/g)

Dry biomass excludes water. Divide by elapsed days only when reporting a rate (kcal/day), not total energy (kcal).

Controls

More options
Full procedure

Your team has a flat of 40 Fast Plants growing under a light bank at 24 °C. Harvest about 10 plants early in the life cycle (day 7) and 10 more later (day 14). For each harvest: pull the plants with all their roots, wash and blot them, weigh each one wet, then dry them at 100 °C for 48 hours and weigh them again.

Plant age (days)—
Plants left (plants)—
Last harvest: mean wet mass (g)—
Last harvest: mean dry mass (g)—
Balance precision (g)0.001

Advance to day 7, then harvest.

The page computes the means and standard error. You compute the last three columns: percent biomass = dry ÷ wet × 100; energy per plant = mean dry mass × 4.35 kcal/g; average daily gain = energy per plant ÷ age in days (the energy stored per day, on average, since the seed was planted). This is not NPP: NPP is the gain between your two harvests, which you calculate below.

Show individual harvest measurements

The full raw harvest table is available here. Use the summary above for calculations.

From NPP to GPP

NPP between your two harvests is the biomass the average plant added per day, converted to kcal. To estimate GPP you also need the energy the plants spent on respiration. Seal 5 living plants in a dark 2.0 L chamber with a CO2 sensor for 10 minutes (no photosynthesis in the dark, so the CO2 rise is respiration only). Do this on the same day as a harvest so you know the plants' mean dry mass.

1 ppm CO2 in 2.0 L of air ≈ 0.00364 mg CO2  ·  1 g CO2 respired ≈ 0.68 g biomass ≈ 2.97 kcal

Controls

The chamber uses plants of the current age in your flat; they are returned afterward unharmed.

Plant age (days)—
Start CO₂ (ppm)—
End CO₂ (ppm)—
CO₂ rise in 10 min (ppm)—

Your plant energy diagram (Step 6)

Drawn to scale from your two harvests (NPP) and your respiration measurement (kcal per plant per day). GPP shows "measure respiration first" until you have measured R. Light energy was not measured.

Procedure 2 · Structured inquiry

Energy flow from producer to consumer

Controls

Each run is one barn. Run at least 3 barns so you can calculate standard error.

More options

A common assumption is that larvae are 40% dry mass and using your Fast Plant percentage for sprouts. Both are assumptions you can test.

Full procedure

Weigh one large fresh Brussels sprout, cut it in half, and place both halves in a clean Brassica Barn. Weigh a group of 8–12 fourth-instar larvae, add them, and let them feed for 3 days. Each day, the frass (droppings) falls onto a paper-towel pad; you collect it, dry it, and weigh it. After 3 days, weigh the larvae again and weigh what is left of the sprout.

A cut sprout also loses water to evaporation, which has nothing to do with eating. A second sprout in an identical barn with no larvae (a control) lets you correct for that.

Time since feeding (days)0
Sprout mass (g)—
Larvae, whole group (g)—
Dry frass (g)—

Your energy audit for Barn 1 (Table 3)

Work per larva over the 3 days. Use the ratios you chose above. Each answer is checked against your own earlier entries, so one slip does not ruin the rest.

All barns: where did the energy go?

The page applies the same calculations to every barn (your chosen ratios; evaporation correction set by the checkbox). Bars show mean ± 2 SE (≈ 95% confidence interval).

Animated energy budget (mean per larva, 3 days)

Designing and conducting your investigation

Ask your own energy question

Pick a question that came up while you worked. Some starting points: Do all plants have the same percentage of biomass? How much energy does it cost an animal to process different plant sources? What limits productivity? Choose one organism, one independent variable, and hold everything else constant.

Controls

Levels to test
More options

Analyzing and evaluating results

Close the energy audit

How do I interpret the energy budget?
  1. Keep the energy terms separate. Distinguish gross primary productivity, energy used in respiration, and net primary productivity before comparing values.
  2. Check units and time. Compare energy or biomass changes over matching areas and time intervals; a total and a rate are not interchangeable.
  3. Follow the transfers. Use your data to describe how energy moves between trophic levels and why less is available at higher levels.
  4. Evaluate uncertainty. Consider sampling variation, estimates of dry mass, and energy-conversion assumptions when supporting your claim.

Your energy budget is a model based on measurements and assumptions; explain which values were measured and which were estimated.

Scientific reasoning self-check (optional)

Review your explanation before submitting. These checkpoints are reminders, not automatic grading or evaluation of your writing.

  • My claim identifies the energy transfer or productivity comparison being tested.
  • I cite measured biomass or energy values with matching units and time intervals.
  • I distinguish gross productivity, respiration and net productivity when explaining energy flow.
  • I describe uncertainty from sampling or conversion assumptions.

If something is missing, revisit your measurements and revise your explanation. Your writing is not automatically scored here.

Evaluate and reflect

How good is your accounting?

Wrap up

Save and hand in your work

Prepare a mini-poster from your Part 3 results: question, hypothesis, methods, a graph with error bars, your energy diagram, and a claim supported by evidence.