Investigation 1

Artificial Selection

Can extreme selection change expression of a quantitative trait in a population in one generation?

Unit 7: Natural SelectionEVO-1.FEVO-1.GScience Practice 4.B≈ 7 weeks of short sessions (wet lab) · 2 periods (online)About 115 minutes in total
Overview

What you'll investigate

Darwin built his case for natural selection partly on what breeders already knew: if you let only certain individuals reproduce, the next generation looks different. In this lab your class raises a population of about 150 Wisconsin Fast Plants (Brassica rapa), measures a trait that varies, lets only the most extreme 10% breed, and checks whether their offspring are different.

In the real lab this takes about seven weeks of short daily visits to a light box. Here you will do the same steps in a virtual growth chamber: count leaf hairs (trichomes) under a magnifier, build a histogram, choose parents, cross-pollinate them with a bee stick, and grow and score generation 2. Then you will design your own selection experiment.

Learning objectives
  • EVO-1.F Explain how humans can affect diversity within a population.
  • EVO-1.G Explain the relationship between changes in the environment and evolutionary changes in the population.
  • Science Practice 4.B Describe data from a table or graph (histograms, means, standard deviation, error bars).
  • Use descriptive statistics to decide whether a population's genetic makeup changed, and design a follow-up investigation about one trait.
Safety (wet lab)

Plants grow under electric light banks with water reservoirs. Keep water and fertilizer solution away from wires, plugs and ballasts, and refill reservoirs carefully. Wash hands after handling soil and fertilizer.

Background

Variation, heredity and differential reproduction

Key ideas
  • Natural selection needs two things: variation in a trait, and heritable variation (differences that come from genes).
  • Quantitative traits such as hair number are polygenic and vary continuously, so you describe them with histograms, means and SD.
  • Heritability h² is the genetic share of the variation: h² = VG / VP.
  • Selection differential S (how extreme the parents are) predicts the response R = h² × S, so offspring regress part of the way back.
  • A control line bred from random parents shows what happens without selection.

Natural selection is differential reproduction: some individuals leave more surviving offspring than others because of the traits they have. If those traits are inherited, the next generation has a different genetic makeup. That change in a population's gene pool over generations is evolution. In nature the environment does the "choosing." In artificial selection, people decide which individuals breed. Corn, dogs and broccoli (a close relative of your Fast Plants) were all shaped this way.

Selection only works when two things are true. First, individuals must vary in the trait. Second, at least part of that variation must be heritable, meaning it comes from differences in genes rather than only from differences in light, water or chance.

Quantitative traits

Mendel's pea traits come in clear categories, such as purple or white. Many traits instead vary on a continuum: height, number of flowers, number of hairs. These quantitative traits are usually polygenic: many genes each add a small amount, and the environment adds more variation on top. The result is a spread of values that you describe with a histogram, a mean, a median and a standard deviation.

Fast Plants have small hairs called trichomes on their leaves and stems. Some plants have none and some have more than 50 along the edge of one leaf. Trichomes may discourage insects such as cabbage white butterfly caterpillars from eating or laying eggs, but making them costs the plant energy.

Predicting the response to selection

Phenotypic variance (VP) has a genetic part (VG) and an environmental part (VE). Heritability, h², is the fraction that is genetic. Breeders use it to predict how far the next generation will move:

VP = VG + VE    h² = VG / VP
S = (mean of selected parents) − (mean of whole population)    R = h² × S

S is the selection differential (how extreme your chosen parents are) and R is the response (how much the offspring mean shifts). If h² were 1, offspring would be as extreme as their parents. If h² were 0, offspring would look like the original population no matter which parents you chose. Real traits fall in between, so offspring usually "regress" part of the way back toward the original mean.

S (selection differential) R Generation 1 (all plants) Selected parents Generation 2 (dashed) Trichome number →
Selecting the hairiest tail shifts the next generation by R = h²S. With h² ≈ 0.5, generation 2 moves about halfway toward the parents' mean.

One round of strong selection can shift the mean noticeably, but it rarely changes the population all the way. Your job is to measure the shift, decide whether it is bigger than chance, and explain it.

What this simulation models
  • Process: Artificial selection on trichome (leaf hair) number in Wisconsin Fast Plants: you choose which plants become parents, and the next generation’s distribution shifts.
  • Included: Hair number, height and stem color each come from many genes with small additive effects plus random environmental variation (heritability about 0.5 for hairs). Alleles pass on by Mendel’s rules. You set the share selected, population size, growing conditions and herbivore damage (which changes plants but is not inherited).
  • Simplified or left out: No dominance, linkage, mutation or gene interactions, and every seed grows. Real plants face pests, failed pollination and counting mistakes, so real shifts are usually smaller and noisier.
Pre-lab check

Before you start

You do not need to master everything first: you will build understanding from your own data. These questions make sure you have the tools you need.

Procedure Steps 1–5 · Structured inquiry

Grow generation 1 and score trichomes

Before you begin: Count the trichomes on each plant and record its score. Then select parents using the recorded traits.

Need a quick science reminder?

Trichomes are tiny hairlike structures on a plant. Record the same trait for every plant; don't confuse a plant's score with the population mean.

Controls

Plant under magnifier—
More options
Histogram bin width

Full procedure

Your class planted 150 seeds, six to a bottle, in 25 soda-bottle wick systems under a light bank. The plants are now 7–12 days old and the class has picked trichome number as the trait to select. To make counts repeatable, everyone uses the same sampling rule: count the hairs along the right-hand margin of the first true leaf.

  1. Tap a seedling in the growth chamber to put its first true leaf under the magnifier.
  2. Tap each hair along the right margin to mark it (tap again to unmark). Hairs on the left margin are not counted.
  3. Press Record my count. Your count is compared with a careful recount, the way a lab partner would double-check. Hand-count at least 5 plants.
  4. Then press Auto-count the rest to score the remaining plants (as if your classmates scored their bottles) and build the class histogram.

Your hand counts. Fidelity check: how close are your counts to the recount? Large differences tell you the counting method needs work.

Growth chamber, top view. Scored plants show their count; the plant under the magnifier is outlined.
Zoom 1×. Zoom in, then drag the leaf to move it.
Magnifier (≈10×), backlit against a dark card. Count only the right margin.
Hairs marked (hairs)0
Plants scored (plants)0
Mean (hairs)—
Median (hairs)—
Range (hairs)—
SD (hairs)—

Review your counts and the histogram above before selecting parents. Use the Record my count action in the scoring controls; the table below updates with each recorded plant.

Procedure Steps 6–10

Choose the parents and cross-pollinate them

Controls

Direction of selection
More options

Full procedure

Directional selection pushes a trait one way. As a class, pick the hairiest (or least hairy) 10% of the whole population. In the real lab you mark those plants and snip the tops off every other plant in your bottles, then move the selected bottles to a separate light box so no stray pollen reaches them.

Fast Plants are self-incompatible: a flower cannot be fertilized by its own plant's pollen. On days 14–16 you collect pollen on a bee stick (a dried honeybee glued to a toothpick) and brush it across every flower of every selected plant, then repeat for three days with the same stick. The unselected plants are pollinated with a different stick so the two groups never mix.

Parents selected (plants)—
Parents' mean (hairs)—
Parents' SD (hairs)—
Flowers pollinated (flowers)0
Procedure Steps 11–14

Score generation 2 and compare

Controls

Full procedure

Seeds from the selected parents were planted under identical conditions: same light bank, new soil and wicks, same fertilizer. At 7–12 days old, score the plants the same way you scored generation 1. You can hand-count some generation 2 plants in the scoring tool above (choose the population from the menu), then score the rest here.

Further rounds use the direction and fraction set in the step above. The control line breeds from a random sample of the same number of plants. One round is the basic experiment; run more rounds to see whether the response continues, slows or stops.

Gen 1 mean (hairs)—
Gen 2 mean, selected (hairs)—
Gen 2 mean, control (hairs)—
Welch t, Gen 2 vs Gen 1—

Calculate the response yourself

Use the means in the table below. S = parents' mean − generation 1 mean. R = generation 2 (selected line) mean − generation 1 mean. Realized heritability h² = R ÷ S.

Designing and conducting your investigation

Your own selection experiment

Controls

Direction
More options

Full procedure

Now ask your own question. You might select in the other direction, select a different quantitative trait (plant height or the amount of purple anthocyanin in the stem), change how strong selection is, or ask how much of the variation comes from the environment. Uneven growing conditions or early herbivore damage (caterpillars chewing the cotyledons) change what plants look like without changing their genes.

Start mean (trait units)—
Final mean, selected (trait units)—
Final mean, control (trait units)—
Welch t, final gen—
Analyzing and evaluating results

Did evolution happen?

Selection: which means do I compare?

Selection differential: selected parents − original population.

Response to selection: offspring − original population.

Label each mean by generation before subtracting.

How do I interpret selection across generations?
  1. Label the populations. Identify the original population, selected parents, and offspring before comparing means.
  2. Separate selection from response. The selection differential describes how the chosen parents differ from the original population; the response describes how the offspring differ from the original population.
  3. Use evidence and uncertainty. Compare the means and variation in your results. If you use a t-test, interpret its result alongside sample size and the observed effect.
  4. Evaluate the claim. Explain whether the offspring data support a heritable response to selection, and identify a limitation or alternative explanation.

A change in one generation is evidence to evaluate, not proof that every future generation will change the same way.

Two-sample t-test

Compare two populations' means. Type your own numbers, press Use my data to fill them from your simulation, or press Show a worked example for clearly labelled sample numbers (never saved as your work). If |t| is larger than the critical value, the difference is unlikely to be chance alone (p < 0.05).

Population A
Population B
Difference (same units as the means)—
t—
df, Welch—
Critical t, 0.05—

Questions

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Scientific reasoning self-check (optional)

Review your own explanation before submitting. These checkpoints are reminders, not automatic grading or evaluation of your writing.

  • My claim compares the original population with offspring after selection.
  • I use the appropriate population means and distinguish the selection differential from the response.
  • I explain how heritable variation and differential reproduction could produce the pattern.
  • I discuss sampling variation or another limitation before generalizing.

If something is missing, revisit your measurements and revise your explanation. Your writing is not automatically scored here.

Evaluate and extend

Where can you go from here?

A common question is why these plants make hairs at all, when building them costs energy. Is there an environment where hairy plants do better? That is the start of a testable hypothesis.

Wrap up

Save and hand in your work

Your tables and answers save in this browser. Your virtual plants, scored counts and the choices you made in the simulation are also saved, so reloading the page brings your work back. A simulation run that is still playing when you leave stops, so let it finish first.